Director: Gene Stupnitsky
Cast: Jennifer Lawrence, Andrew Barth Feldman, Laura Benanti, Matthew Broderick, Natalie Morales, Scott MacArthur, Ebon Moss-Bachrach, Hasan Minhaj, Kyle Mooney, Zahn McClarnon
Genre: Comedy
Run Time: 103 min
Opens: 27 July 2023
Rating: M18
The concept of a movie star has become a nebulous thing. You’ve probably read think-pieces aplenty about how franchises and intellectual property are the movie stars now. Jennifer Lawrence maybe have been in lower key fare for the past few years, but she’s still got movie star clout. After winning an Oscar and headlining sci-fi franchises, she’s doing the next logical thing: a sex comedy.
Montauk resident Maddie Barker (Jennifer Lawrence) is having a rough go of it. She’s an Uber driver who has just gotten a car towed and she is in danger of losing the house her mother left her. Desperate, she answers a strange ad on Craigslist. Wealthy couple Laird (Matthew Broderick) and Allison (Laura Benanti) Becker are looking for a young woman to help their 19-year-old son Percy (Andrew Barth Feldman) come out of his shell. Intelligent and talented but socially awkward and very sheltered, Laird and Allison are hoping someone will help, uh, “date” Percy in exchange for a Buick Regal. However, Percy cannot know that his parents made this arrangement. And so, Maddie attempts to get Percy to fall for her and to lose his virginity before he heads off to college, but complications ensue, as they must, and Maddie finds herself in over her head.
No Hard Feelings is the kind of movie you don’t see a lot of in theatres now: an R-rated (M18 in Singapore) comedy being released during the summer (it opened in June in the US). One would argue that there is a place for movies like this amidst the big tentpole franchise movies, and that the more types of movies get made, the better. Director Gene Stupnitsky also made the 2019 movie Good Boys, an R-rated comedy starring kids. Naturally, the premise of No Hard Feelings is dubious and might make many uncomfortable, because it carries the connotations of an older person grooming a younger one, even though at 19, Percy is an adult. No Hard Feelings makes it clear that the arrangement at its centre is a bad idea, but it has great empathy for its characters even as they are put in sometimes-humiliating circumstances. Perhaps surprisingly for a sex comedy, No Hard Feelings is sweet.
The movie’s warmth is often at odds with its raunchiness, and there are times when it feels like it is a sex comedy against its will. The big moment that more than earns it its R-rating, involving nudity from Lawrence in a comedic context, is funny and over-the-top but also feels a bit incongruent with the rest of the movie. It feels like No Hard Feelings is very restrained and trying very hard to play things safe, while also doing enough such that it can be categorised as a sex comedy. Some had hoped that this would hark back to the post-American Pie boom of teen sex comedies, and this is very much not that kind of movie. The promotional materials describe No Hard Feelings as “edgy”, and it isn’t, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing.
The writing in the movie is often funny and everything moves along as a pleasant clip, but it’s its pair of stars that really make No Hard Feelings work. Jennifer Lawrence produces as well as starring, and she commits to a role that is silly, but that she’s able to bring dimensionality to. She never once acts like this is beneath her and invites the audience to laugh along with her and not at her. She proves herself an adept physical comedian and plays the kind of role that Cameron Diaz might have been cast in with a good deal of heart too.
Andrew Barth Feldman is a musical theatre actor who played the title role in Dear Evan Hansen on Broadway. We’ve seen this character type before: painfully shy and socially inept but ultimately loveable. Feldman is absolutely endearing throughout the movie, and the chemistry he shares with Lawrence, which must be somewhat romantic but also playful and friendly, is compulsively watchable. Plus, he gets to sing, performing an unexpectedly moving rendition of a certain Hall and Oates classic. Laura Benanti and Matthew Broderick are also welcome presences as Percy’s overprotective parents.
Summary: No Hard Feelings is a surprisingly sweet movie that is being sold as a raunchy sex comedy. While the movie does have nudity and sexuality, it seems almost reluctant to just be a sex comedy and has an amiable warmth to it. Jennifer Lawrence and Andrew Barth Feldman are very well matched as co-stars: she’s game for the physical comedy while he’s endearing and easy to root for. It’s not the American Pie-style comeback for the sex comedy genre some might have hoped for and is really a lot timider than the marketing suggests, but it’s rare that anything like this still opens in theatres, and it’s worthwhile for that.
RATING: 3.5 out of 5 Stars
Jedd Jong