Director: Chris Buck, Fawn Veerasunthorn
Cast: Ariana DeBose, Chris Pine, Alan Tudyk, Angelique Cabral, Victor Garber, Natasha Rothwell, Jennifer Kumiyama, Harvey Guillén, Niko Vargas, Evan Peters, Ramy Youssef, Jon Rudnitsky, Della Saba
Genre: Animation
Run Time: 95 min
Opens: 23 November 2023
Rating: PG
At some point in many musicals, the protagonist sings an “I Want” song. The Disney animated canon is filled with “I Want” songs, from “I’m Wishing” to “Part of Your World” to “Out There” to “A Place Called Slaughter Race”. At the heart of each “I Want” song is a wish, and now there’s a Disney movie all about that wish.
The Kingdom of Rosas is ruled by King Magnifico (Chris Pine) and Queen Amaya (Angelique Cabral). Magnifico has mastered sorcery and has the power to grant wishes. When each citizen of Rosas turns 18, they hand over their wish to Magnifico, and he guards the wishes, choosing which one to grant. Asha (Ariana DeBose), a young tour guide, wants to become Magnifico’s apprentice. She also hopes for the king to grant her grandfather Sabino’s (Victor Garber) wish, as it is his 100th birthday. When Magnifico refuses, Asha learns he is abusing his power. She makes her own wish, and is visited by Star, the star that she wished upon. Star’s magical gifts include giving Asha’s pet goat Valentino (Alan Tudyk) the power of speech. Meanwhile, Magnifico feels threatened by a magical presence that he cannot wield control over and grows ever more tyrannical. It is up to Asha, her friends and Star to free the wishes that Magnifico is holding captive and return them to the people of Rosas.
Wish has its charming moments and some very endearing characters, especially Star. The magical entity has adorable facial expressions, is round and cuddly, and demonstrates an economy of design. The idea is that this is the star that “When You Wish Upon a Star” from Pinocchio is about.
The voice acting is great, especially from leads DeBose and Pine. Asha and Magnifico are generic in many ways, but DeBose and Pine lend their characters life and personality. Pine seems to be having a grand old time hamming it up as the cackling villain, while DeBose gets to show off her wonderful voice in several musical numbers. Magnifico will be a fun character for cast members at Disney parks to play and have interactions with visitors. Alan Tudyk, who has been Disney’s good luck charm for a decade now, is entertaining as the talking goat Valentino, delivering a vocal performance that is reminiscent of his turn as Clayface in the Harley Quinn animated series.
Wish is intended as a centennial celebration for Disney, and long-time Disney fans will have fun spotting the various Easter eggs and references to Disney movies past scattered throughout the movie. Everything from Bambi and Robin Hood to Peter Pan and Mary Poppins gets a shout-out of some kind.
Unfortunately, Wish often feels like it exists mainly because of a corporate mandate. It feels caught between trying to honour Disney films past and standing on its own. As a result, it feels oddly rigid and flat, lacking in crucial dynamism. The animation is largely technically proficient, but the Kingdom of Rosas is no Corona from Tangled or Arendelle from Frozen. The animation style seeks to blend the classic watercolour look of something like Snow White with the recent CGI 3D animation seen in most Disney animated features. It is somewhat reminiscent of the now-defunct Telltale Games’ art style. Sometimes it looks interesting, but other times it feels a little cheap.
Asha has a posse of seven friends modelled on the Seven Dwarves, and it seems like the only reason there are seven of those characters is to make that reference. Sometimes the references are fun, but other times they can feel shoehorned in. The story is a simplistic enough fairy tale for children to grasp, but all those references are aimed at adults, and Wish doesn’t bridge that divide as well as some other Disney movies have.
The movie has the chance to comment on the nature of wishing, on the difference between hoping something will happen and trying to make it happen; on how wishes can inspire us but also hold us back. Careful the wish you make, wishes are children – that sort of thing. Wish isn’t really interested in any of this, and that’s fine too.
The songs by Julia Michaels and Benjamin Rice feel more in the Lin-Manuel Miranda mould than the Alan Menken mould. Asha’s big number “This Wish” is catchy, but it being in all the trailers is a big contributing factor. It’s all a matter of personal taste, of course, but this reviewer feels a movie that’s meant to celebrate the entirety of Disney animation should have a more classic, throwback sound. Wish’s songs feel like contemporary musical theatre, sitting somewhere between Miranda and Pasek and Paul. They’re not terrible by any means, but fall short of Disney’s most memorable, sweeping songs.
Summary: Wish features a wonderful voice cast led by Ariana DeBose and Chris Pine and largely technically competent animation. It’s a straightforward fairy tale, but it also feels burdened by the corporate mandate of commemorating the 100th anniversary of the Walt Disney Company. Wish fits in as many references to Disney movies past as it can but comes off feeling underwhelming rather than triumphant. Enough of it works, but it feels like a shadow of the studio’s greatest hits. There still are plenty of funny and moving moments, but it often feels like something is holding Wish back. Stay through the end credits to see illustrations representing Disney’s animated feature films (in chronological order) and for a sweet little post-credits scene.
RATING: 3 out of 5 Stars
Jedd Jong